What to Include in Your Acknowledgments Section
Most academic papers have many people who have helped in some way in the preparation of the written version or the research itself.
This could be someone from a sponsoring institution, a funding body, other researchers, or even family, friends or colleagues who have helped in the preparation.
Acknowledgment sections are always present in both papers and academic theses. For papers, the Acknowledgments section is usually presented at the back, whereas in a thesis, this section is located towards the front of the manuscript and is commonly placed somewhere between the abstract and introduction. (However, the exact location varies between each university, as each establishment possesses its own style guide for theses and student submissions. So, it is always worthwhile consulting your university’s academic style guide before writing a manuscript for undergraduate/postgraduate submission.)
For academic theses, there is no right or wrong way to acknowledge people, and who you want to acknowledge is down to personal preference. However, the common types of people authors acknowledge in their academic theses include:
- Their supervisor’s contributions
- The research group (especially if the thesis in question is a master’s and the work is helped along by a PhD student)
- The support staff (laboratory technicians etc.)
- Any students who undertook side projects with them (e.g. final year undergraduates, summer students, master’s students)
- Administrative staff (there can be a lot of bureaucracy for thesis submissions)
- The referees that got them onto the course (postgraduate only)
- Their funding bodies
- Any collaboration with industry and the people they worked with at said establishment(s)
Now, whilst university manuscripts can include any combination of the above (including all and none in some cases), academic publications in journals more commonly acknowledge the same kind of people/organizations, but again it is up to the author(s) what they feel should be acknowledged (not every piece of help needs to be acknowledged, just the most useful/prevalent help). Acknowledgments should also be written in the first person.
Examples of what should be acknowledged in a journal publication are listed below:
- Direct technical help (e.g. supply of animal subjects, cells, equipment setup, methods, statistics/data manipulation, samples, chemicals/reagents, analytical/spectroscopy techniques)
- Indirect assistance (topical and intellectual discussions about the research which can lead to generation of new ideas)
- Affiliated Institutions
- Funding bodies
- Grant numbers
- Who received the funding (if not the author- e.g. a supervisor)
- Any associated fellowships
Aside from who to include in your Acknowledgments section, it should also be sated that titles such as Mr, Mrs, Miss etc are not commonly included, but honorary titles such as Dr, Professor etc. are. The institutions of the acknowledged people are usually mentioned.
Also, it is not common practice for the lead paper writer (i.e. the person writing and publishing the manuscript) to acknowledge the other authors/direct contributors to the paper. Only those who are not recognized as authors may be thanked and acknowledged. Authors are also not allowed to thank reviewers personally, or those who inspire them but cannot directly receive their appreciation – although reviewers can be thanked if they are kept anonymous. Unlike university manuscripts, journal manuscripts should not include help and guidance from family and friends.
Other style points for the acknowledgments include not using pronouns indicating possession (i.e. his, her, their, etc.) and terms associated with specific companies should be written out in full, e.g. Limited, Corporation etc. If the results have been published elsewhere, then this should also be acknowledged. The tone of the section should be in an active voice and any abbreviations should be expanded unless the abbreviation appears in the main body of the text.
Below are a couple of examples of Acknowledgments sections taken from a couple of papers from the Nature Communications Journal:
In addition, work dedicated to people directly, such as those who are deceased, may be included in the Acknowledgments section, but this must be done in a certain way and the appreciation put into an open dialogue.
“We dedicate this work to the deceased Prof. Bloggs” would not be accepted, whereas:
“We acknowledge Prof. Bloggs for discovering the secret of anonymity” would be accepted.
Many people think that the Acknowledgments section of a manuscript is a trivial and unimportant component; however, they constitute a vital means to ensure that all affiliated support for the paper can be duly and transparently mentioned. By acknowledging people for their efforts and contributions, you demonstrate your integrity as an academic researcher. In addition, crediting other people for their help can also increase their presence in the academic world and possibly help to boost their career as well as your own.
If you need help with your submissions then please contact us or keep a look out for our upcoming offers and discounts.
American Journal Experts - http://www.aje.com/en/arc/editing-tip-writing-acknowledgments/
Duan L., Hope J., Ong Q., Lou H-Y., Kim N., McCarthy C., Acero V., Lin M., Cui B., Understanding CRY2 interactions for optical control of intracellular signalling, Nature Communications, 2017, 8:547
Xu Q., Jensen K., Boltyanskiy R., Safarti R., Style R., Dufresne E., Direct measurement of strain-dependent solid surface stress, Nature Communications, 2017, 8:555